Cabinet
may give nod for more teeth to NCW next week
It seems to
be one of very dreadful news for our country. When our country is suffering
from biased laws having 49 women centric laws with us but no place where a man
can go and plead against injustice to them. There are so many examples where
man are forced to the judicial process after immediate arrest by police in
woman laws and after long trials of years they get acquitted from courts. The
rate of charge sheeting is so high in woman laws that for man it is definite to
face the court process unnecessarily for years only on the basis of allegations
of a woman. Look at the scenario presented by NCRB in 2013 report-
Rape
|
Dowry death
|
509 IPC
|
498A IPC
|
DP Act
|
|
Charge sheeting rate in 2013
|
95.8
|
94
|
96.1
|
92.3
|
>90
|
Rape
|
Dowry death
|
509 IPC
|
498A IPC
|
DP Act
|
|
Conviction rate
|
27.1
|
32.3
|
32
|
16
|
32.3
|
It definitely
raises questions on the investigations done by police before they submit charge
sheet. Definitely it is due to lack of proper investigation by police that a
man has to suffer the pain of arrest and long judicial process. Finding this
injustice Honable Supreme court gave a landmark judgement Arnesh Kumar vs State Of Bihar & Anr on 2
July, 2014 and put a bar on illegal arrests and
detentions by police as well as judiciary.
This judgment
came as a relief for many trapped in false #498a cases. But still as there is
no punishment for false cases in woman laws being given so number of cases
going up only. False cases and arrests directly correlates with man’s self
respect and dignity, hence many gets break down and forced to suicide.
Year
|
Cases
|
Arrests
|
Conviction
(at lower court)
|
Suicides by husband
|
2009
|
89546
|
174395
|
21%
|
58192
|
2010
|
94041
|
180413
|
20.9%
|
61453
|
2011
|
99135
|
180701
|
20.6%
|
64323
|
2012
|
106527
|
197762
|
15%
|
65979
|
2013
|
118866
|
222091
|
15.2%
|
68756
|
And now we
are talking to give powers of a court to NCW seems to be a dreadful step
towards injustice. When our Supreme court has mentioned its concern over false
cases and illegal arrests followed with them, in Sushil Kumar Sharma vs Union Of India And Ors on
19 July, 2005
Supreme court
has termed the misuse of 498a IPC as “Legal Terrorism”. There are so many
examples and judgements that showed that woman are mis-using this law to settle
personal scores and extort money.
There has
always been a doubt on the working of Women commission. Also there were many cases
revealing that many are fraud NGO’s working on the commission’s money.
90% of
NGOs seeking funds under WCD scheme found fake
False cases behind
Delhi's tag of rape capital: Court
53.2 per cent rape cases filed between April 2013-July 2014 false, says DCW
http://indiatoday.intoday.in/story/false-rape-cases-in-delhi-delhi-commission-of-women/1/409320.html
PIL seeks
guidelines for registering rape cases as 75% result in acquittal
MISUSE OF DOMESTIC VIOLENCE ACT ON
RISE: JSCW
Recently stated
that 70% DV cases are false.
Domestic violence cases rise, conviction rate goes downhill in Gujarat
http://www.dnaindia.com/india/report-domestic-violence-cases-rise-conviction-rate-goes-downhill-in-gujarat-2000205
Harvard
study says 70 percent of domestic violence is committed by women against men
In this
scenario when our judiciary is concerned about false cases and started the
following-
· -Fine
to false case filers.
· -Guidelines
not to arrest illegally
· -Affidavits
to be submitted along with statements in cases.
· -Termed
misuse as “Legal Terrorism”
· -Termed
those mis-using 498a IPC as “Disgruntled wives”
It is to be
believed that this step of giving arrest powers to NCW will be a black day for
justice. Few questions comes to my mind-
*Will
it not be again a situation of illegal arrests by NCW which SC has curbed down
little a bit by order to follow CRPC 41?
*Considering
the biasness of NCW will it not be a gross injustice to Man?
*Considering the number of false cases registered who will compensate for the loss of dignity and self respect of Man after arrest by NCW?
*Considering the number of false cases registered who will compensate for the loss of dignity and self respect of Man after arrest by NCW?
*Considering the biasness of NCW and fraud NGO working under it, will it be in justice to give powers to arrest to NCW?
Woman fined Rs 1 lakh for false domestic violence case
IIT Topper Fights
and Wins Own Dowry Harassment Case
Delhi HC
frees 5 men, says false rape charges destroy lives
Man has
nowhere to go against injustice due to lack of Men’s commission. They are
forced into the long judicial process and harassment. Many of them looses hope
and surrenders and very few like above dares to fight against injustice, but
their fight is very long as our judiciary only disposes 15% cases/year
registered under woman laws. The step will not only futile the attempt of SC to
prevail justice but also be the reasons for breaking many families.
I collected
few responses against this, they are very genuine responses of sufferers, those
fighting for Men’s rights (MRA) and common man-
Better kill all husbands &men directly or Ban marriages
in India
Response 2 Amendments 2 the National Commission4Women Act,
1990
Instead of torturing
Men. it is better to Divide EARTH in two parts and give half to Women #FakeCases
Better give #NCW gun
power to kill men. Mental torture gives more pain
Torturing men is more
easier now. Cheers!
Court
power to NCW will b highly misused. better ban marriages.
Arrest power2biased #NCW is not
only unfair bt killing Natural Justice #StopAbuseofMen
Government must think before implementing this and
must not give powers of arrest to NCW. Definitely it will kill justice and
increase the biasness. It is better to be following gender neutrality in laws
as crime has no gender, many cases of woman killing her husband are found but
still the “Abla nari” tag of woman must be abolished.
(Views are personal)
No comments:
Post a Comment